Our Menu

Our Ice Cream

We like to give you options. So, we’re stocked with several flavors of hand-dipped, old-fashioned ice cream. But, it doesn’t stop there! With endless topping options like our popular hot fudge and crunchy pecan pralines, there is something for everyone to enjoy.

We even created West Virginia’s signature treat! The Caverns Sundae includes cavernous ingredients like vanilla and salted caramel flavored ice cream topped with warm maple syrup, caramel drizzle, chocolate rocks, whipped cream, AND our homemade almond brittle. Yum!

Ice Cream Menu

Choice of cake cone or dish

1 scoop $3.25
2 scoop $4.75
3 scoop $6.25
4 scoop $7.75
*waffle cone $0.75 / sugar cone $0.25

Pup Cup / $1.00

Whipped cream and pb sauce

Sundaes

1 scoop $4.45
2 scoop $5.95
3 scoop $7.45
*includes choice of sauce, whipped cream & cherry

Toppings & Sauces / $0.75/each

Chocolate
Caramel
Strawberry
Peanut Butter
Hot Fudge
Marshmallow
Maple Syrup + $1.25

Any Flavor Milkshake / $7.75

16 oz.
*includes choice of sauce, whipped cream & cherry

The Caverns Sundae / $6.50

Vanilla and salted caramel ice cream topped with caramel drizzle, warm maple syrup, chocolate rocks, almond praline, whipped cream and caramel drizzle.

Our Sandwiches

We love being your go-to shop for delectable sweet treats but it didn’t take long after opening for us to realize we could go a step beyond. Introducing: The Caverns Sandwiches! We’re proudly sourcing our amazing bread from local bakeries like Bolivar Bread Company and Great Harvest Bread Company.

We pile our sandwiches high with only the finest deli meats and cheeses then pair these creations with complimentary sauces and toppings. Is your mouth watering too?
In addition, we also serve up delicious soups & chili, hot dogs, vegan sandwich options, and more! Check out our full menu then stop by or call in a pick-up order today.

**All sandwiches are served with kettle chips and a pickle.
**Sandwiches served until 7 pm Tuesday thru Sunday

Sandwiches

The Jefferson / $12.00

Roast beef, corned beef, pepper jack, provolone, tomato, and onion with our special sauce on a buttered roll and steamed to perfection.
– steamed

The Reuben / $12.00

Corned beef or turkey, swiss, sauerkraut and mustard on buttered rye bread and served with thousand island dressing on the side.
– grilled

Caprese / $12.00

Fresh mozzarella, fresh basil, tomato, and balsamic glaze on buttered ciabatta roll.
– steamed or grilled
Add prosciutto 3.00

The Pappy / $12.00

Pastrami, swiss and dijon mustard on buttered rye bread – grilled.
Add tomato .75

The Claar / $12.00

Tofu with our own special seasoning, vegan tahini mayo, green peppers, cucumbers, tomatoes, onions, and sprouts on vegan sourdough bread.

Grilled Cheese Sandwich / $8.00

Provolone & white cheddar on buttered white bread.
Add tomato .75
Add bacon 2.00

Build Your Own Sandwich / $12.00

Choose one meat, one cheese, three toppings and a sauce on either white, wheat or sourdough bread.

Hot dogs

The Caverns Dog

1/4 lb. All natural 100% beef, served on a buttered brioche bun w/ a side of chips & pickle.
Plain / $7.00
NY Dog / $8.00
sauerkraut & yellow mustard
WV Dog / $9.00
chili, coleslaw & yellow mustard
Chili Dog / $9.00
chili & cheddar cheese

Kids Menu

Hot dog / $6.00
Grilled cheese / $6.00
*includes chips, pickle & juice box

Salads

Cranberry Cashew / $12.25
House Chef Salad / $12.25

Chili

Cheddar cheese and sour cream served with buttered bread
cup $5.00 bowl $7.00

Drinks

Black Dog Coffee

Creamer

Whole Milk
Half & Half
Heavy Cream
Oat Milk 1.00

Hot Tea

12oz $2.25
16oz $2.50
20oz $2.75

Hibiscus Breeze / $5.00

Bottled Water / $2.00

Bottled Drinks / $4.00

Juices / Teas / Craft Sodas

Freshly Brewed Iced Tea / $3.00

Sweet / Unsweet